Bug 569312: Speed up the adding of many FKs to the same table for MySQL

Bugzilla/DB.pm

@@ -447,12 +447,14 @@ sub bz_setup_foreign_keys {
     my @tables = $self->_bz_schema->get_table_list();
     foreach my $table (@tables) {
         my @columns = $self->_bz_schema->get_table_columns($table);
+        my %add_fks;
         foreach my $column (@columns) {
             my $def = $self->_bz_schema->get_column_abstract($table, $column);
             if ($def->{REFERENCES}) {
-                $self->bz_add_fk($table, $column, $def->{REFERENCES});
+                $add_fks{$column} = $def->{REFERENCES};
             }
         }
+        $self->bz_add_fks($table, \%add_fks);
     }
 }
 
@@ -506,19 +508,36 @@ sub bz_add_column {
 
 sub bz_add_fk {
     my ($self, $table, $column, $def) = @_;
+    $self->bz_add_fks($table, { $column => $def });
+}
+
+sub bz_add_fks {
+    my ($self, $table, $column_fks) = @_;
 
+    my %add_these;
+    foreach my $column (keys %$column_fks) {
         my $col_def = $self->bz_column_info($table, $column);
-    if (!$col_def->{REFERENCES}) {
-        $self->_check_references($table, $column, $def);
+        next if $col_def->{REFERENCES};
+        my $fk = $column_fks->{$column};
+        $self->_check_references($table, $column, $fk);
+        $add_these{$column} = $fk;
         print get_text('install_fk_add',
-                       { table => $table, column => $column, fk => $def }) 
+                       { table => $table, column => $column, fk => $fk })
             . "\n" if Bugzilla->usage_mode == USAGE_MODE_CMDLINE;
-        my @sql = $self->_bz_real_schema->get_add_fk_sql($table, $column, $def);
+    }
+
+    return if !scalar(keys %add_these);
+
+    my @sql = $self->_bz_real_schema->get_add_fks_sql($table, \%add_these);
     $self->do($_) foreach @sql;
-        $col_def->{REFERENCES} = $def;
+
+    foreach my $column (keys %add_these) {
+        my $col_def = $self->bz_column_info($table, $column);
+        $col_def->{REFERENCES} = $add_these{$column};
         $self->_bz_real_schema->set_column($table, $column, $col_def);
-        $self->_bz_store_real_schema;
     }
+
+    $self->_bz_store_real_schema();
 }
 
 sub bz_alter_column {
@@ -700,11 +719,11 @@ sub bz_add_field_tables {
         $self->_bz_add_field_table($ms_table,
             $self->_bz_schema->MULTI_SELECT_VALUE_TABLE);
 
-        $self->bz_add_fk($ms_table, 'bug_id', {TABLE => 'bugs',
-                                               COLUMN => 'bug_id',
-                                               DELETE => 'CASCADE'});
-        $self->bz_add_fk($ms_table, 'value',  {TABLE  => $field->name,
-                                               COLUMN => 'value'});
+        $self->bz_add_fks($ms_table, 
+            { bug_id => {TABLE => 'bugs', COLUMN => 'bug_id',
+                         DELETE => 'CASCADE'},
+
+              value  => {TABLE  => $field->name, COLUMN => 'value'} });
     }
 }
 

Bugzilla/DB/Schema.pm

@@ -210,6 +210,9 @@ update this column in this table."
 
 use constant SCHEMA_VERSION  => '2.00';
 use constant ADD_COLUMN      => 'ADD COLUMN';
+# Multiple FKs can be added using ALTER TABLE ADD CONSTRAINT in one
+# SQL statement. This isn't true for all databases.
+use constant MULTIPLE_FKS_IN_ALTER => 1;
 # This is a reasonable default that's true for both PostgreSQL and MySQL.
 use constant MAX_IDENTIFIER_LEN => 63;
 
@@ -1817,11 +1820,26 @@ sub _hash_identifier {
 }
 
 
-sub get_add_fk_sql {
-    my ($self, $table, $column, $def) = @_;
+sub get_add_fks_sql {
+    my ($self, $table, $column_fks) = @_;
 
+    my @add;
+    foreach my $column (keys %$column_fks) {
+        my $def = $column_fks->{$column};
         my $fk_string = $self->get_fk_ddl($table, $column, $def);
-    return ("ALTER TABLE $table ADD $fk_string");
+        push(@add, $fk_string);
+    }
+    my @sql;
+    if ($self->MULTIPLE_FKS_IN_ALTER) {
+        my $alter = "ALTER TABLE $table ADD " . join(', ADD ', @add);
+        push(@sql, $alter);
+    }
+    else {
+        foreach my $fk_string (@add) {
+            push(@sql, "ALTER TABLE $table ADD $fk_string");
+        }
+    }
+    return @sql;
 }
 
 sub get_drop_fk_sql { 

Bugzilla/DB/Schema/Oracle.pm

@@ -35,6 +35,7 @@ use Carp qw(confess);
 use Bugzilla::Util;
 
 use constant ADD_COLUMN => 'ADD';
+use constant MULTIPLE_FKS_IN_ALTER => 0;
 # Whether this is true or not, this is what it needs to be in order for
 # hash_identifier to maintain backwards compatibility with versions before
 # 3.2rc2.
@@ -136,40 +137,44 @@ sub get_drop_index_ddl {
 # - Delete CASCADE
 # - Delete SET NULL
 sub get_fk_ddl {
-    my ($self, $table, $column, $references) = @_;
-    return "" if !$references;
-
-    my $update    = $references->{UPDATE} || 'CASCADE';
-    my $delete    = $references->{DELETE};
-    my $to_table  = $references->{TABLE}  || confess "No table in reference";
-    my $to_column = $references->{COLUMN} || confess "No column in reference";
-    my $fk_name   = $self->_get_fk_name($table, $column, $references);
-
-    # 'ON DELETE RESTRICT' is enabled by default   
-    $delete = "" if ( defined $delete && $delete =~ /RESTRICT/i);
+    my $self = shift;
+    my $ddl = $self->SUPER::get_fk_ddl(@_);
 
-    my $fk_string = "\n     CONSTRAINT $fk_name FOREIGN KEY ($column)\n"
-                    . "     REFERENCES $to_table($to_column)\n";
+    # iThe Bugzilla Oracle driver implements UPDATE via a trigger.
+    $ddl =~ s/ON UPDATE \S+//i;
+    # RESTRICT is the default for DELETE on Oracle and may not be specified.
+    $ddl =~ s/ON DELETE RESTRICT//i;
 
-    $fk_string    = $fk_string . "     ON DELETE $delete" if $delete; 
+    return $ddl;
+}
 
-    if ( $update =~ /CASCADE/i ){
-        my $tr_str = "CREATE OR REPLACE TRIGGER ${fk_name}_UC"
-                     . " AFTER UPDATE OF $to_column ON $to_table "
-                     . " REFERENCING "
-                     . " NEW AS NEW "
-                     . " OLD AS OLD "
-                     . " FOR EACH ROW "
-                     . " BEGIN "
-                     . "     UPDATE $table"
-                     . "        SET $column = :NEW.$to_column"
-                     . "      WHERE $column = :OLD.$to_column;"
-                     . " END ${fk_name}_UC;";
-        my $dbh = Bugzilla->dbh; 
-        $dbh->do($tr_str);      
+sub get_add_fks_sql {
+    my $self = shift;
+    my ($table, $column_fks) = @_;
+    my @sql = $self->SUPER::get_add_fks_sql(@_);
+
+    foreach my $column (keys %$column_fks) {
+        my $fk = $column_fks->{$column};
+        next if $fk->{UPDATE} && uc($fk->{UPDATE}) ne 'CASCADE';
+        my $fk_name   = $self->_get_fk_name($table, $column, $fk);
+        my $to_column = $fk->{COLUMN};
+        my $to_table  = $fk->{TABLE};
+
+        my $trigger = <<END;
+CREATE OR REPLACE TRIGGER ${fk_name}_UC
+          AFTER UPDATE OF $to_column ON $to_table
+              REFERENCING NEW AS NEW OLD AS OLD
+             FOR EACH ROW
+                    BEGIN
+                   UPDATE $table
+                      SET $column = :NEW.$to_column
+                    WHERE $column = :OLD.$to_column;
+                      END ${fk_name}_UC;
+END
+        push(@sql, $trigger);
     }
 
-    return $fk_string;
+    return @sql;
 }
 
 sub get_drop_fk_sql {