-Add scheduler optimization options, short circuit all predicates if one predicate fails

examples/scheduler-policy-config-with-extender.json

@@ -26,5 +26,6 @@
         "nodeCacheCapable": false
 	}
     ],
-"hardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight" : 10
+"hardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight" : 10,
+"alwaysCheckAllPredicates" : false
 }

examples/scheduler-policy-config.json

@@ -15,5 +15,6 @@
 	{"name" : "ServiceSpreadingPriority", "weight" : 1},
 	{"name" : "EqualPriority", "weight" : 1}
 	],
-"hardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight" : 10
+"hardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight" : 10,
+"alwaysCheckAllPredicates" : false
 }

pkg/scheduler/api/types.go

@@ -47,6 +47,12 @@ type Policy struct {
 	// corresponding to every RequiredDuringScheduling affinity rule.
 	// HardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight represents the weight of implicit PreferredDuringScheduling affinity rule, in the range 1-100.
 	HardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight int32
+
+	// When AlwaysCheckAllPredicates is set to true, scheduler checks all
+	// the configured predicates even after one or more of them fails.
+	// When the flag is set to false, scheduler skips checking the rest
+	// of the predicates after it finds one predicate that failed.
+	AlwaysCheckAllPredicates bool
 }
 
 type PredicatePolicy struct {

pkg/scheduler/api/v1/types.go

@@ -39,6 +39,12 @@ type Policy struct {
 	// corresponding to every RequiredDuringScheduling affinity rule.
 	// HardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight represents the weight of implicit PreferredDuringScheduling affinity rule, in the range 1-100.
 	HardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight int `json:"hardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight"`
+
+	// When AlwaysCheckAllPredicates is set to true, scheduler checks all
+	// the configured predicates even after one or more of them fails.
+	// When the flag is set to false, scheduler skips checking the rest
+	// of the predicates after it finds one predicate that failed.
+	AlwaysCheckAllPredicates bool `json:"alwaysCheckAllPredicates"`
 }
 
 type PredicatePolicy struct {

pkg/scheduler/core/extender_test.go

@@ -317,7 +317,7 @@ func TestGenericSchedulerWithExtenders(t *testing.T) {
 		}
 		queue := NewSchedulingQueue()
 		scheduler := NewGenericScheduler(
-			cache, nil, queue, test.predicates, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, test.prioritizers, algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer, extenders, nil, schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{})
+			cache, nil, queue, test.predicates, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, test.prioritizers, algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer, extenders, nil, schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{}, false)
 		podIgnored := &v1.Pod{}
 		machine, err := scheduler.Schedule(podIgnored, schedulertesting.FakeNodeLister(makeNodeList(test.nodes)))
 		if test.expectsErr {

pkg/scheduler/core/generic_scheduler.go

@@ -90,16 +90,17 @@ func (f *FitError) Error() string {
 }
 
 type genericScheduler struct {
-	cache                 schedulercache.Cache
-	equivalenceCache      *EquivalenceCache
-	schedulingQueue       SchedulingQueue
-	predicates            map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate
-	priorityMetaProducer  algorithm.MetadataProducer
-	predicateMetaProducer algorithm.PredicateMetadataProducer
-	prioritizers          []algorithm.PriorityConfig
-	extenders             []algorithm.SchedulerExtender
-	lastNodeIndexLock     sync.Mutex
-	lastNodeIndex         uint64
+	cache                    schedulercache.Cache
+	equivalenceCache         *EquivalenceCache
+	schedulingQueue          SchedulingQueue
+	predicates               map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate
+	priorityMetaProducer     algorithm.MetadataProducer
+	predicateMetaProducer    algorithm.PredicateMetadataProducer
+	prioritizers             []algorithm.PriorityConfig
+	extenders                []algorithm.SchedulerExtender
+	lastNodeIndexLock        sync.Mutex
+	lastNodeIndex            uint64
+	alwaysCheckAllPredicates bool
 
 	cachedNodeInfoMap map[string]*schedulercache.NodeInfo
 	volumeBinder      *volumebinder.VolumeBinder
@@ -133,7 +134,7 @@ func (g *genericScheduler) Schedule(pod *v1.Pod, nodeLister algorithm.NodeLister
 
 	trace.Step("Computing predicates")
 	startPredicateEvalTime := time.Now()
-	filteredNodes, failedPredicateMap, err := findNodesThatFit(pod, g.cachedNodeInfoMap, nodes, g.predicates, g.extenders, g.predicateMetaProducer, g.equivalenceCache, g.schedulingQueue)
+	filteredNodes, failedPredicateMap, err := findNodesThatFit(pod, g.cachedNodeInfoMap, nodes, g.predicates, g.extenders, g.predicateMetaProducer, g.equivalenceCache, g.schedulingQueue, g.alwaysCheckAllPredicates)
 	if err != nil {
 		return "", err
 	}
@@ -295,6 +296,7 @@ func findNodesThatFit(
 	metadataProducer algorithm.PredicateMetadataProducer,
 	ecache *EquivalenceCache,
 	schedulingQueue SchedulingQueue,
+	alwaysCheckAllPredicates bool,
 ) ([]*v1.Node, FailedPredicateMap, error) {
 	var filtered []*v1.Node
 	failedPredicateMap := FailedPredicateMap{}
@@ -313,7 +315,7 @@ func findNodesThatFit(
 		meta := metadataProducer(pod, nodeNameToInfo)
 		checkNode := func(i int) {
 			nodeName := nodes[i].Name
-			fits, failedPredicates, err := podFitsOnNode(pod, meta, nodeNameToInfo[nodeName], predicateFuncs, ecache, schedulingQueue)
+			fits, failedPredicates, err := podFitsOnNode(pod, meta, nodeNameToInfo[nodeName], predicateFuncs, ecache, schedulingQueue, alwaysCheckAllPredicates)
 			if err != nil {
 				predicateResultLock.Lock()
 				errs[err.Error()]++
@@ -402,6 +404,7 @@ func podFitsOnNode(
 	predicateFuncs map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate,
 	ecache *EquivalenceCache,
 	queue SchedulingQueue,
+	alwaysCheckAllPredicates bool,
 ) (bool, []algorithm.PredicateFailureReason, error) {
 	var (
 		equivalenceHash  uint64
@@ -457,8 +460,6 @@ func podFitsOnNode(
 					fit, reasons, invalid = ecache.PredicateWithECache(pod.GetName(), info.Node().GetName(), predicateKey, equivalenceHash)
 				}
 
-				// TODO(bsalamat): When one predicate fails and fit is false, why do we continue
-				// checking other predicates?
 				if !eCacheAvailable || invalid {
 					// we need to execute predicate functions since equivalence cache does not work
 					fit, reasons, err = predicate(pod, metaToUse, nodeInfoToUse)
@@ -479,6 +480,11 @@ func podFitsOnNode(
 				if !fit {
 					// eCache is available and valid, and predicates result is unfit, record the fail reasons
 					failedPredicates = append(failedPredicates, reasons...)
+					// if alwaysCheckAllPredicates is false, short circuit all predicates when one predicate fails.
+					if !alwaysCheckAllPredicates {
+						glog.V(5).Infoln("since alwaysCheckAllPredicates has not been set, the predicate evaluation is short circuited and there are chances of other predicates failing as well.")
+						break
+					}
 				}
 			}
 		}
@@ -917,7 +923,7 @@ func selectVictimsOnNode(
 	// that we should check is if the "pod" is failing to schedule due to pod affinity
 	// failure.
 	// TODO(bsalamat): Consider checking affinity to lower priority pods if feasible with reasonable performance.
-	if fits, _, err := podFitsOnNode(pod, meta, nodeInfoCopy, fitPredicates, nil, queue); !fits {
+	if fits, _, err := podFitsOnNode(pod, meta, nodeInfoCopy, fitPredicates, nil, queue, false); !fits {
 		if err != nil {
 			glog.Warningf("Encountered error while selecting victims on node %v: %v", nodeInfo.Node().Name, err)
 		}
@@ -931,7 +937,7 @@ func selectVictimsOnNode(
 	violatingVictims, nonViolatingVictims := filterPodsWithPDBViolation(potentialVictims.Items, pdbs)
 	reprievePod := func(p *v1.Pod) bool {
 		addPod(p)
-		fits, _, _ := podFitsOnNode(pod, meta, nodeInfoCopy, fitPredicates, nil, queue)
+		fits, _, _ := podFitsOnNode(pod, meta, nodeInfoCopy, fitPredicates, nil, queue, false)
 		if !fits {
 			removePod(p)
 			victims = append(victims, p)
@@ -1045,18 +1051,20 @@ func NewGenericScheduler(
 	priorityMetaProducer algorithm.MetadataProducer,
 	extenders []algorithm.SchedulerExtender,
 	volumeBinder *volumebinder.VolumeBinder,
-	pvcLister corelisters.PersistentVolumeClaimLister) algorithm.ScheduleAlgorithm {
+	pvcLister corelisters.PersistentVolumeClaimLister,
+	alwaysCheckAllPredicates bool) algorithm.ScheduleAlgorithm {
 	return &genericScheduler{
-		cache:                 cache,
-		equivalenceCache:      eCache,
-		schedulingQueue:       podQueue,
-		predicates:            predicates,
-		predicateMetaProducer: predicateMetaProducer,
-		prioritizers:          prioritizers,
-		priorityMetaProducer:  priorityMetaProducer,
-		extenders:             extenders,
-		cachedNodeInfoMap:     make(map[string]*schedulercache.NodeInfo),
-		volumeBinder:          volumeBinder,
-		pvcLister:             pvcLister,
+		cache:                    cache,
+		equivalenceCache:         eCache,
+		schedulingQueue:          podQueue,
+		predicates:               predicates,
+		predicateMetaProducer:    predicateMetaProducer,
+		prioritizers:             prioritizers,
+		priorityMetaProducer:     priorityMetaProducer,
+		extenders:                extenders,
+		cachedNodeInfoMap:        make(map[string]*schedulercache.NodeInfo),
+		volumeBinder:             volumeBinder,
+		pvcLister:                pvcLister,
+		alwaysCheckAllPredicates: alwaysCheckAllPredicates,
 	}
 }

pkg/scheduler/core/generic_scheduler_test.go

@@ -187,16 +187,17 @@ func TestSelectHost(t *testing.T) {
 func TestGenericScheduler(t *testing.T) {
 	predicates.SetPredicatesOrdering(order)
 	tests := []struct {
-		name          string
-		predicates    map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate
-		prioritizers  []algorithm.PriorityConfig
-		nodes         []string
-		pvcs          []*v1.PersistentVolumeClaim
-		pod           *v1.Pod
-		pods          []*v1.Pod
-		expectedHosts sets.String
-		expectsErr    bool
-		wErr          error
+		name                     string
+		predicates               map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate
+		prioritizers             []algorithm.PriorityConfig
+		alwaysCheckAllPredicates bool
+		nodes                    []string
+		pvcs                     []*v1.PersistentVolumeClaim
+		pod                      *v1.Pod
+		pods                     []*v1.Pod
+		expectedHosts            sets.String
+		expectsErr               bool
+		wErr                     error
 	}{
 		{
 			predicates:   map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate{"false": falsePredicate},
@@ -377,6 +378,22 @@ func TestGenericScheduler(t *testing.T) {
 			expectsErr: true,
 			wErr:       fmt.Errorf("persistentvolumeclaim \"existingPVC\" is being deleted"),
 		},
+		{
+			// alwaysCheckAllPredicates is true
+			predicates:               map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate{"true": truePredicate, "matches": matchesPredicate, "false": falsePredicate},
+			prioritizers:             []algorithm.PriorityConfig{{Map: EqualPriorityMap, Weight: 1}},
+			alwaysCheckAllPredicates: true,
+			nodes: []string{"1"},
+			pod:   &v1.Pod{ObjectMeta: metav1.ObjectMeta{Name: "2"}},
+			name:  "test alwaysCheckAllPredicates is true",
+			wErr: &FitError{
+				Pod:         &v1.Pod{ObjectMeta: metav1.ObjectMeta{Name: "2"}},
+				NumAllNodes: 1,
+				FailedPredicates: FailedPredicateMap{
+					"1": []algorithm.PredicateFailureReason{algorithmpredicates.ErrFakePredicate, algorithmpredicates.ErrFakePredicate},
+				},
+			},
+		},
 	}
 	for _, test := range tests {
 		cache := schedulercache.New(time.Duration(0), wait.NeverStop)
@@ -393,7 +410,7 @@ func TestGenericScheduler(t *testing.T) {
 		pvcLister := schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister(pvcs)
 
 		scheduler := NewGenericScheduler(
-			cache, nil, NewSchedulingQueue(), test.predicates, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, test.prioritizers, algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer, []algorithm.SchedulerExtender{}, nil, pvcLister)
+			cache, nil, NewSchedulingQueue(), test.predicates, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, test.prioritizers, algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer, []algorithm.SchedulerExtender{}, nil, pvcLister, test.alwaysCheckAllPredicates)
 		machine, err := scheduler.Schedule(test.pod, schedulertesting.FakeNodeLister(makeNodeList(test.nodes)))
 
 		if !reflect.DeepEqual(err, test.wErr) {
@@ -414,7 +431,7 @@ func TestFindFitAllError(t *testing.T) {
 		"2": schedulercache.NewNodeInfo(),
 		"1": schedulercache.NewNodeInfo(),
 	}
-	_, predicateMap, err := findNodesThatFit(&v1.Pod{}, nodeNameToInfo, makeNodeList(nodes), predicates, nil, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, nil, nil)
+	_, predicateMap, err := findNodesThatFit(&v1.Pod{}, nodeNameToInfo, makeNodeList(nodes), predicates, nil, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, nil, nil, false)
 
 	if err != nil {
 		t.Errorf("unexpected error: %v", err)
@@ -449,7 +466,7 @@ func TestFindFitSomeError(t *testing.T) {
 		nodeNameToInfo[name].SetNode(&v1.Node{ObjectMeta: metav1.ObjectMeta{Name: name}})
 	}
 
-	_, predicateMap, err := findNodesThatFit(pod, nodeNameToInfo, makeNodeList(nodes), predicates, nil, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, nil, nil)
+	_, predicateMap, err := findNodesThatFit(pod, nodeNameToInfo, makeNodeList(nodes), predicates, nil, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, nil, nil, false)
 	if err != nil {
 		t.Errorf("unexpected error: %v", err)
 	}
@@ -1276,7 +1293,7 @@ func TestPreempt(t *testing.T) {
 			extenders = append(extenders, extender)
 		}
 		scheduler := NewGenericScheduler(
-			cache, nil, NewSchedulingQueue(), map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate{"matches": algorithmpredicates.PodFitsResources}, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, []algorithm.PriorityConfig{{Function: numericPriority, Weight: 1}}, algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer, extenders, nil, schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{})
+			cache, nil, NewSchedulingQueue(), map[string]algorithm.FitPredicate{"matches": algorithmpredicates.PodFitsResources}, algorithm.EmptyPredicateMetadataProducer, []algorithm.PriorityConfig{{Function: numericPriority, Weight: 1}}, algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer, extenders, nil, schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{}, false)
 		// Call Preempt and check the expected results.
 		node, victims, _, err := scheduler.Preempt(test.pod, schedulertesting.FakeNodeLister(makeNodeList(nodeNames)), error(&FitError{Pod: test.pod, FailedPredicates: failedPredMap}))
 		if err != nil {

pkg/scheduler/factory/factory.go

@@ -130,6 +130,9 @@ type configFactory struct {
 
 	// Handles volume binding decisions
 	volumeBinder *volumebinder.VolumeBinder
+
+	// always check all predicates even if the middle of one predicate fails.
+	alwaysCheckAllPredicates bool
 }
 
 // NewConfigFactory initializes the default implementation of a Configurator To encourage eventual privatization of the struct type, we only
@@ -880,6 +883,12 @@ func (f *configFactory) CreateFromConfig(policy schedulerapi.Policy) (*scheduler
 	if policy.HardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight != 0 {
 		f.hardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight = policy.HardPodAffinitySymmetricWeight
 	}
+	// When AlwaysCheckAllPredicates is set to true, scheduler checks all the configured
+	// predicates even after one or more of them fails.
+	if policy.AlwaysCheckAllPredicates {
+		f.alwaysCheckAllPredicates = policy.AlwaysCheckAllPredicates
+	}
+
 	return f.CreateFromKeys(predicateKeys, priorityKeys, extenders)
 }
 
@@ -933,7 +942,7 @@ func (f *configFactory) CreateFromKeys(predicateKeys, priorityKeys sets.String,
 		glog.Info("Created equivalence class cache")
 	}
 
-	algo := core.NewGenericScheduler(f.schedulerCache, f.equivalencePodCache, f.podQueue, predicateFuncs, predicateMetaProducer, priorityConfigs, priorityMetaProducer, extenders, f.volumeBinder, f.pVCLister)
+	algo := core.NewGenericScheduler(f.schedulerCache, f.equivalencePodCache, f.podQueue, predicateFuncs, predicateMetaProducer, priorityConfigs, priorityMetaProducer, extenders, f.volumeBinder, f.pVCLister, f.alwaysCheckAllPredicates)
 
 	podBackoff := util.CreateDefaultPodBackoff()
 	return &scheduler.Config{

pkg/scheduler/scheduler_test.go

@@ -533,7 +533,8 @@ func setupTestScheduler(queuedPodStore *clientcache.FIFO, scache schedulercache.
 		algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer,
 		[]algorithm.SchedulerExtender{},
 		nil,
-		schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{})
+		schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{},
+		false)
 	bindingChan := make(chan *v1.Binding, 1)
 	errChan := make(chan error, 1)
 	configurator := &FakeConfigurator{
@@ -577,7 +578,8 @@ func setupTestSchedulerLongBindingWithRetry(queuedPodStore *clientcache.FIFO, sc
 		algorithm.EmptyMetadataProducer,
 		[]algorithm.SchedulerExtender{},
 		nil,
-		schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{})
+		schedulertesting.FakePersistentVolumeClaimLister{},
+		false)
 	bindingChan := make(chan *v1.Binding, 2)
 	configurator := &FakeConfigurator{
 		Config: &Config{