• Jinoh Kang's avatar
    combase: Prevent use-after-free due to a race with proxy_manager_destroy. · e308b19a
    Jinoh Kang authored
    Today, find_proxy_manager() may return a proxy manager that is about to
    be freed.  This happens when the proxy manager's reference count reaches
    zero, but proxy_manager_destroy() has not removed the proxy manager from
    the apartment proxy list.
    
    Fix this by incrementing the reference count only if it is already
    nonzero.  If the reference count is zero, any reference to the proxy
    manager will become invalid after the current thread leaves the critical
    section (apt->cs).  This is because proxy_manager_destroy() will proceed
    to destroy the proxy manager after the apartment lock (apt->cs) is
    released.
    
    An alternative solution would be to prevent find_proxy_manager from
    observing the zero reference count in the first place.  Multiple
    approaches have been considered for implementing this solution, but were
    eventually dropped due to several disadvantages when applied to the
    current Wine codebase:
    
    1. Always acquire the apartment lock from the proxy manager's Release()
       method, and hold the lock until the proxy manager is completely
       removed from the list if the reference count drops to zero.
    
       This requires handling the special case when the proxy manager's
       parent apartment has been destroyed.  When an apartment is destroyed,
       it sets the `parent` field of each proxy manager that was previously
       owned by the apartment to NULL.  This means that each access to
       `This->parent->cs` has to be guarded by a NULL check for
       `This->parent`.
    
       Even if `parent` were never NULL, unconditionally acquiring a lock
       may unnecessarily block the subroutine and introduce contention.
    
    2. Opportunistically decrement the reference count without holding the
       lock, but only if the count is greater than 1.  This approach is
       still not free from the NULL parent apartment problem.
    
    3. Check for any concurrent reference count change from
       proxy_manager_destroy(), and bail out if such change has occurred.
       This makes it possible for the proxy manager's AddRef() method to
       return 1, which is unusual.
    e308b19a
Name
Last commit
Last update
..
tests Loading commit data...
Makefile.in Loading commit data...
apartment.c Loading commit data...
combase.c Loading commit data...
combase.spec Loading commit data...
combase_private.h Loading commit data...
dcom.idl Loading commit data...
errorinfo.c Loading commit data...
hglobalstream.c Loading commit data...
irpcss.idl Loading commit data...
malloc.c Loading commit data...
marshal.c Loading commit data...
roapi.c Loading commit data...
rpc.c Loading commit data...
string.c Loading commit data...
stubmanager.c Loading commit data...
usrmarshal.c Loading commit data...